Discussion on proper shoes

What shoe is the best for this hike? Here are the pros and cons of popular choices.

Hiking boots
Pros
 * 1) You probably own a pair
 * 2) Ankle support
 * 3) Waterproof

Cons
 * 1) May get stuck in deep mud
 * 2) Heavy
 * 3) Apt to get soaked unless you buy gaiters
 * 4) Changing socks to avoid blisters

Spiked tabis
Pros
 * 1) All terrain
 * 2) Proven in Alakai Wilderness
 * 3) Can be purchased at Fukuda Seed store in Kalihi or probably at fishing shops like Hanapa'a.

Cons
 * 1) May have to buy